Download this study as a PDF
PDFs in other languages are translated automatically from the original article.
What decision does everyone have to make about Jesus?
Mark 2:5-7 – When Jesus saw their faith, he said unto the sick of the palsy, Son, thy sins be forgiven thee. But there was certain of the scribes sitting there, and reasoning in their hearts, Why doth this man thus speak blasphemies? who can forgive sins but God only?
Note: Jesus did not merely proclaim good moral teachings. He repeatedly claimed for himself an authority that, according to the very scribes who were present, belongs to God alone: to forgive sins. The New Testament presents this authority as given to him by the Father, because he is the Son of God (cf. John 5:22-27). Such a claim hardly allows for a neutral position.
The literary scholar C. S. Lewis made this argument well known; later it was often shortened to the formula “Lord, liar, or lunatic?” Anyone who claims such authority for himself cannot simply have been “just a great moral teacher.” Three possibilities remain:
1. Liar: He knew that this authority was not his, and deliberately deceived people. Hard to reconcile with a teaching that calls for honesty throughout, and with the willingness of eyewitnesses to die for this very claim (see the previous study).
2. Lunatic: He believed it himself, although it was not true. Hard to reconcile with the psychological balance and clarity of the rest of his teaching, which even critical historians acknowledge.
3. He told the truth.
An obvious objection: perhaps Jesus never said this himself, and later followers attributed it to him (the “legend” option). This is exactly the objection we have already dealt with in the previous study: early dating, accuracy in detail, the criterion of embarrassment. Anyone who accepts these arguments can no longer escape the conclusion here.
Why is history alone not enough to truly know Jesus?
John 7:16-17 – Jesus answered them, and said, My doctrine is not mine, but his that sent me. If any man will {is willing to} do his will, he shall know of the doctrine, whether it be of God, or whether I speak of myself.
Note: In John 7:16-17, Jesus himself points to a middle way. It does not mean first understanding everything completely and only then following, nor simply accepting everything without testing whether it is reliable. It means acknowledging the overwhelming historical evidence and the positive impact of his teachings on personal morals, on society and on every other area of life, and giving him a chance without being able to explain absolutely everything.
Anyone who seriously puts this to the test still has very concrete experiences today, as countless people report: in honest prayer, when asking Jesus for guidance or a sign; in providential events that, looking back, fit too precisely to be coincidence, such as an encounter or an answer at exactly the right moment; or in difficult situations, where people report healing or provision for which, in hindsight, they can find no natural explanation.
Such experiences cannot be archived or cited like historical facts. Each one on its own could also be explained differently. A skeptic will always find room for doubt. But taken together, across millions of people and many centuries, these real and deeply personal experiences form a pattern that is just as convincing as any historical argument.
Aren’t experiences with Jesus simply imagination or self-persuasion?
1 John 4:1 – Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God: because many false prophets are gone out into the world.
Note: The question is legitimate, and the Bible itself calls for exactly this caution: not to believe blindly, but to test. Psychologically, it is clear that people reinterpret coincidences in hindsight to fit, overinterpret experiences under emotional pressure, and talk themselves into things. This is real and should not be played down. Even so, two observations speak against dismissing every such experience wholesale as self-deception:
1. Some providential events are so precise that they are hard to explain as mere wishful thinking, such as an answer that fits exactly a question never spoken aloud, or timing that no one could have known in advance. Autosuggestion does not normally produce verifiably correct details that a person did not know beforehand.
2. Many report lasting changes in behavior that go against their immediate self-interest: addiction overcome, thoughts of revenge given up, a radical reorientation of life. Self-deception rarely produces costly, lasting changes that run counter to one’s own immediate advantage.
Still, any single experience, taken on its own, is not necessarily conclusive. That is why experience deliberately does not stand alone here, but alongside the historical foundation from the previous study. Anyone who considers both together has a broader basis than either argument on its own.
What do I have to lose if I give Jesus an honest chance?
Psalm 34:8 – O taste and see that the LORD is good: blessed is the man that trusteth in him.
Note: “Taste and see” is an invitation, not a condition. You do not have to settle every question conclusively before giving Jesus an honest chance. The test suggested here is simple: it examines true, genuine Christianity, not the behavior of churches or of individuals who call themselves Christians. You listen to what Jesus himself taught, and measure him by this fruit of his own.
This distinction matters. In the name of Christ, churches have for centuries often done the opposite of what he taught: wars, persecution, hypocrisy. That is a verdict on people who disregarded his teaching, not on the teaching itself. Anyone who wants to test Jesus should therefore start with his own words, for example the Sermon on the Mount: love for enemies instead of retaliation (Matthew 5:44), forgiveness instead of resentment (Matthew 6:14-15), humility instead of status. Applied consistently, these commandments produce a life that hardly anyone would seriously call harmful or unreasonable, even someone who does not believe in their divine origin.
The risk in this is small. In the worst case, what remains is a life that has grown in honesty, readiness to forgive, and love for one’s neighbor, quite apart from whether every open question is settled in the end. Anyone who waits until every doubt is removed waits in vain, because no one in this world can answer every doubt.
Footnotes
Version: 2026-11-19 / JESUS_en
Notes: Comments or additions by the author are marked as “Note” or with curly braces {}.
Support: ScriptureQnA.com is free and has no advertising, but every new translation of these studies costs money. If this study has helped you, please consider a donation, so that others can read it in their own language too. You will find the details on the homepage of ScriptureQnA.com.
Bible quotes: Passages are quoted from the King James Version (KJV), also known as the Authorized Version. ScriptureQnA.com is published in the European Union, where the KJV is in the public domain. In the United Kingdom, rights in the Authorized Version are vested in the Crown. Readers there who print or share these studies should observe the terms of the Crown’s patentee, Cambridge University Press.
AI: This Bible study was reworded and checked with the help of AI. The English version has been reviewed by a person. If you notice a mistake, please let us know at contact@ScriptureQnA.com.
